OPINIONS
Editorials
Commentaries
Columnists

Doctors with house-call practices shouldn't take heat

By Barbara J. McKee
Tribune Columnist

March 7, 2006

How would you like to have your doctor available to you whenever you have a problem? How would you feel if all you had to do was pick up the phone to be able to see your doctor in a matter of hours? What would you pay to have that comfort?

There's a growing trend lately to provide such a doctor. These physicians are called "concierge" or "boutique" doctors.

Physicians who are fed up with crowded waiting rooms, long hours and huge case loads are looking for a better way to treat the sick without massive overload. For a yearly fee, a physician with such a practice will be at your beck and call.

Physicians are creating group practices that charge a yearly fee and place limits on the number of patients each doctor accepts. Fees can range from around $1,500 to $10,000 a year, depending on what services are included.

Some cry out that this new type of practice is creating a larger schism between the rich and the poor. With the growing shortage of high-quality physicians and nurses, this type of practice violates an unwritten moral code that all doctors should share the burden of indigent and low-reimbursement patients.

Physicians who are part of a boutique practice counter that they are able to give high-quality patient care, fewer hospitalizations and lower office-overhead payouts. Some practices only accept cash and report an increase in productivity. They also say they've reduced operating costs as much as 60 percent.

The insurance companies and the Government Accountability Office of U.S. Health and Human Services aren't thrilled. A federal investigation showed while this kind of medical practice is troubling, concierge physicians accepting insurance payments are using the yearly fees for services not covered by health plans.

I find it funny that these groups are considered immoral. What's wrong with a person earning about $30,000 a year having an on-call personal physician? For around $2,000 a year, which is cheaper than the average deductible and co-pay for a visit to the emergency room, patients of these groups report fewer serious health issues thanks to early detection and same-day appointments that remove the fear of an emergency room visit.

I have a hard time criticizing this style of medical care. With all the cuts to Medicare and Medicaid and the high deductibles and co-pays most people endure, the choice of going outside the norm to receive high-quality medical care becomes a top priority.

The tragedy is the people who will suffer from the bureaucracy that drives this shift in medical care. If this country wants high-quality medical care for everyone, then let's make it happen. The entire House and one-third of the Senate are up for re-election in November. Now is the time to vote for those who will make the needs of the people a top priority.

McKee, a wheelchair user, is a freelance writer and producer. You can e-mail her at chairgrrl@chairgrrl.com.

MORE MCKEE COLUMNS »

 
Search site for: Search help »