OPINIONS
Editorials
Commentaries
Columnists

Greedy nonprofits swindle disabled workers

By Barbara J. McKee
Tribune Columnist

March 14, 2006

What if I told you there were high-paying government jobs for the severely disabled? I'd be swamped by e-mails or called a liar. But it's true - if you have the right disability.

In 1971, America had an unprecedented number of disabled veterans returning from Vietnam. Many could not return to jobs in the private sector because of prejudices against disabilities, a lack of skills or the inability to find employment because of psychological disabilities.

Congress decided to do the right thing and expanded a little-known program called Javits-Wagner-O'Day. Created in 1930, it set aside government contracts for the blind.

President Nixon's chief employment training official for disabled people, Edward Newman, pushed through Congress a plan to open the program to veterans with missing limbs, paralysis or brain damage, plus 12 million working-age adults left unemployed by major disabilities.

Newman told Congress the expansion would include the mentally impaired, paraplegics, quadriplegics, deaf people with severe psychomotor problems and people with other kinds of neurological impairment such as severe cerebral palsy or epilepsy.

This was a groundbreaking shift in the drive to retrain thousands of people with disabilities to enter mainstream America. But what began as a truly commendable program has turned into a cash cow for greedy nonprofit organizations.

According to the Oregonian, "With the acquiescence of regulators, nonprofits gradually have expanded the notion of severely disabled to include ailments never discussed when the law was amended in 1971. The additions include conditions such as alcoholism or chemical dependency, minor learning disabilities, limited English, nasal polyps, carpal tunnel syndrome, allergies, arthritis and speech impairments. It also has stretched the boundaries of the program's most fundamental rule: 75 percent of the work hours logged by contractors must be supplied by blind or severely disabled workers."

Most of the workers now employed under Javits-Wagner-O'Day are earning wages well above workers with severe disabilities. While the average disabled worker earns minimum wage, under Javits-Wagner-O'Day a worker with back pain can earn between $20-$25 per hour. To add insult to injury, some of the executives of nonprofits receiving contracts under Javits-Wagner-O'Day are earning record salaries - as high as $500,000. The larger nonprofits hire lobbyists and trade groups to secure Javits-Wagner-O'Day contracts.

An investigation into the program seems like a no-brainer. But since 1999, any attempts to cap executive salaries or audit employee records have been squashed.

With so many charities and small nonprofits losing millions in federal support, this program demands a thorough, unflinching house cleaning.

Linda Merrill, chief executive at Envision, a Kansas nonprofit that primarily employs blind workers, told the Oregonian it's time for "severely disabled" to be defined more strictly. "We're kind of joking among ourselves," said Merrill, "that instead of National Industries for the Severely Handicapped, it's National Industries for the Severe Hangnail and Hemorrhoids."

Accountability in government is the joke of the day. I'm not laughing.

McKee, a wheelchair user, is a freelance writer and producer. You can e-mail her at chairgrrl@chairgrrl.com.

MORE MCKEE COLUMNS »

 
Search site for: Search help »